<div id="RTEContent"><pre>Hi Ed,<br><br>>The lightest key in the world will not return<br>> very fast if the capstan is too close to the<br>> balance pin.<br><br>That is interesting to me; The fastest returning<br>keys I have ever seen were on an action that had<br>the capstans moved towards the balance rail in order<br>to reduce the action ratio. This action had no<br>lead weights in the keys at all. Instead, the<br>balance weight was adjusted with magnets. The action<br>ratio was approximately 5.3, if I recall.<br><br>The key return was so fast that many pianists couldn't<br>get used to the feel of the key following their fingers<br>so closely on the way up. Those who loved this piano<br>were for the most part very fast professional players.<br>The lesson learned from this was that some inertia in the<br>keys is required by most players. That amount is however<br>less than one will find in most pianos on the market.<br><br>>><i>In order to achieve that, and
still maintain the proper<br></i>>>static balance weight, the action needs to have a low<br>>>ratio geometry.<br><br>>Is this to say that the high ratio actions will not<br>>repeat as fast? My experience is otherwise.<br><br>It depends on the hammer weights. If two actions have<br>same weight hammers and the same balance weight, but<br>one has a high ratio, the action with the high ratio will<br>have slower returning keys because the keys will have more<br>lead in them.<br><br>>><i><span style="font-family: monospace;"></span></i>A stiff spring setting will help return the key faster.<br><br>>I have not found this to be so. All other things being<br>>equal(and within bounds), there is virtually no measurable<br>>difference in repetition speed between a spring that<br>>throws the hammer off the jack when released from check <br>>and one that simply lifts the hammer just slowly enough<br>>that it can't be felt.<br><br>When the hammer is in
check, the spring pushes the wippen<br>heel against the capstan forcing the key up. While the<br>hammer is checked, neither its weight nor inertia can exert<br>any force on the capstan. That first impetus for the return<br>of the key comes from the repetition spring. As soon as<br>the hammer un-checks, its weight takes over and becomes the<br>restoring force for the key to return to its up position.<br><br>>However, the former makes escapement a clumsy chore for<br>>pp playing.<br><br>As I mentioned, it's a compromise.<br><br>>I still maintain that the major determinate in<br>>repetition speed is the height of check.<br><br>Absolutely true, the less distance the hammer has to<br>move between the check and the string, the faster it<br>can all happen.<br><br>Vladan<br></pre></div><p>
                <hr size=1>Do you Yahoo!?<br>
With a free 1 GB, there's more in store with <a href="http://us.rd.yahoo.com/mail_us/taglines/mailstorage/*http://mail.yahoo.com/">Yahoo! Mail.</a>