<HTML><FONT FACE=arial,helvetica><FONT SIZE=2>In a message dated 1/19/0=
1 6:12:55 PM Central Standard Time, :
<BR>shop@farleyspianos.com (Farley's House of Pianos) writes:
<BR>
<BR>
<BR> "A new CD of Chopin works recorded on a completely restored Steinway mo=
del B
<BR>(1907) in Jean-Baptiste Rameau 1/7 comma meantone is available for sale.=
"
<BR>
<BR>Well, by gosh, he did it! Although I can tell that it was one of h=
is staff
<BR>that wrote the post. Tim is really not the kind of person who uses=
a
<BR>computer.
<BR>
<BR>There is an error in the name of the person who designed the temperament=
. It
<BR>is *Romieu*, not *Rameau*. Jean-Baptiste Romieu and Jean-Philippe =
Rameau are
<BR>definitely not the same person. The 1/7 Comma Meantone Temperament=
was
<BR>designed in 1758 by Romieu. Rameau is known for using an 18th Cent=
ury
<BR>*Modified* Meantone Temperament (a different class of temperaments
<BR>altogether).
<BR>
<BR>I hope as many of you as possible get that CD and express your opinion a=
bout
<BR>it, even those who say they prefer ET. I would expect at least som=
e people
<BR>to say it sounds "out of tune". When I was getting the Baldwin SD-=
10 ready
<BR>for the notorious performance in Albuquerque, I invited 2 gentleme=
n from
<BR>Steinway for an advance hearing of what the tuning would sound like that=
<BR>night. As, the artist practiced the Beethoven "Pathetique" Sonata,=
I was
<BR>thinking how powerful of an impression the temperament gave the "wailing=
<BR>ghost" sounds in the key of F minor.
<BR>
<BR>The Steinway men just laughed and smirked, "Bill, that sounds *out of tu=
ne*!"
<BR> Apparently, some people later on thought so, too. But if you=
'll give it a
<BR>fair listen, I think you'll find what I observed: there is some
<BR>extraordinary beauty the temperament provides that just cannot be heard =
any
<BR>other way. In order to get that really sweet sound, you have to en=
dure what
<BR>sometimes sounds tart and strained.
<BR>
<BR>Bill Bremmer RPT
<BR>Madison, Wisconsin
<BR></FONT></HTML>