<HTML><FONT SIZE=2 FAMILY="SANSSERIF" FACE="Arial" LANG="0">
<BR><BLOCKQUOTE TYPE=CITE style="BORDER-LEFT: #0000ff 2px solid; MARGIN-LEFT: 5px; MARGIN-RIGHT: 0px; PADDING-LEFT: 5px">Date: Fri, 08 Dec 2000 12:03:27 -0800
<BR>From: "Patrick C. Poulson" <ppoulson@jps.net>
<BR>Subject: Spare Me From "Perfect Pitch"!
<BR>
<BR>I went back to check out a Wurlitzer spinet at a school that I tuned
<BR>yesterday, the one that the music teacher said had gone totally flat in the
<BR>bottom octave. Nothing wrong. In fact, a few of the notes had gone a little
<BR>sharp! The teacher played a few notes and said " Can't your hear that these
<BR>bottom notes are a 1/2 step flat?" Well, actually they sounded fine to me,
<BR>but I got my Accutuner out and doublechecked them. They were right where
<BR>they needed to be. The music teacher claims to have perfect pitch. I have
<BR>had experience with some people with "perfect pitch", and it seems that
<BR>sometimes their ear focuses on a harmonic that is out of tune with the rest
<BR>of the harmonics from a string, and there's nothing I can do to change short
<BR>of replacing the piano. The music teacher was busy rehearsing her choir by
<BR>the time I finished, so I called in the prinicipal who is also a piano
<BR>player, fortunately, and explained the situation . She seemed to understand
<BR>, and actually apologized for the music teacher's attitude and abruptness,
<BR>saying that the teacher is under a lot of pressure to get her Christmas
<BR>program together and also has been sick. I was just glad that there was
<BR>nothing structurally wrong with the piano, or that somehow my ears had gone
<BR>totally off - admittedly, the cold I'm getting over has clogged my Eustacian
<BR>tubes up a bit, but I don't think my hearing has been affected.
<BR> Anybody else had a similiar experience? Thanks, Patrick Poulson, RPT
<BR></BLOCKQUOTE>
<BR></FONT><FONT COLOR="#000000" SIZE=3 FAMILY="SERIF" FACE="Bell MT" LANG="0">
<BR>Patrick,
<BR>
<BR>There have been many discussions on the List concerning this phenomenon--in <BR>my experience it is NOT just one thing, nor is it infallible, and people <BR>under pressure frequently find themselves operating with a pitch sense that <BR>is not as reliable as it usually is. But there is one more thing which may <BR>help you--MANY people with "pitch sense," or whatever you wish to call it, <BR>have relied upon it so completely that they are unable to augment that sense <BR>with the things that other musicians learn to do as a matter of course. Your <BR>choral director friend may be one of those, and may NOT be playing with a <BR>full musical deck, so to speak! Don't let it bother you......the sense can <BR>be an aid, but it is not a cure, no matter what some may say...there's more <BR>to being a musician, by far!
<BR>
<BR>Stan Ryberg
<BR>Barrington IL</FONT></HTML>