<HTML><FONT FACE=arial,helvetica><FONT SIZE=2>Time being short, I'll co=
mment on a few points without copying them.
<BR>
<BR>Older tuners in Europe not tuning pure ET: For at least a century,=
ET has been the one and only temperament believed in. All other kinds=
not understood nor having any interest, ET has morphed into a curiously mil=
d but backwards version of a Well Temperament.
<BR>
<BR>This has happened because tuners concentrate too much on trying to make =
the 4ths and 5ths too pure. The temperament sequence begins in the whi=
te keys. A too pure 5th creates a 3rd which is too wide. By the =
end of the sequence, something has to give, so the overly tempered 5ths amon=
g the black keys create 3rds which are too slow. *Voilą*, you get *R=
everse Well*.
<BR>
<BR>The younger generation has learned some of the more advanced aural techn=
iques that came upon the scene about 1980. Many may also use ETDs whic=
h help them get a true ET.
<BR>
<BR>Regarding Chopin in "all the keys" and ET. Most of Chopin's writin=
g is in the more remote keys. The romantic nature of his music and the=
melodic lines are deemed to be enhanced by the use of 19th and late 19th Ce=
ntury Well Temperaments (WT) by most who have discovered them and put them t=
o use. You'll find his writing in the simple keys to be of a different=
nature, more close harmony which is better suited to the smooth and harmoni=
ous sound of those keys in a typical 19th Century WT.
<BR>
<BR>It has also been my observation and thus my belief that virtually all 20=
th Century music, including Jazz is also tonal and adheres to the same basic=
concept. Close, simple harmony is written in the simple, white keys. =
Sweeping, melodic and vibrant music uses the black keys.
<BR>
<BR>Jazz has many mixtures of harmony as well as clashing disonances. =
This however, does not mandate the use of ET, contrary to many people's supp=
osition. Some people have even experimented with Jazz in 1/4 Comma Mea=
ntone and really liked it. I feel that the Victorian or Quasi Equal Te=
mperaments generally serve it best, giving it more clarity and texture than =
ET does.
<BR>
<BR>Since many pianists have been unknowingly and inadvertently subjected to=
Reverse Well, they have learned to do what I would call "bang harder" when =
playing Chopin just to get some kind of color out of the piano where it is l=
acking. For these people, a temperament which curiously goes contrary =
to the basic theories of how most HTs are constructed, why and how they are =
used seems to work.
<BR>
<BR>Ed Foote has experimented with the De Morgan Temperament which does this=
. I created a very mild, nearly equal Victorian Temperament which I so=
metimes transpose up 1/2 step to get this effect. My local colleague, =
Timothy Farley RPT has come up with a brilliant idea which I really like. &n=
bsp;He tunes a very mild, 1/8 Comma Meantone (it has Victorian like 3rds) bu=
t has shifted the "Wolf" from G#-Db to A-E. In this instance, the A ha=
s really become a Bbb (double flat).
<BR>
<BR>His whole white key side of the scale are double flats. E is Fb an=
d B is Cb. This creates a mild kind of reversely focused harmony compa=
red to what is expected from the usual HTs. Those advanced pianists wh=
o largely play Romantic pieces in 4 and 5 flats and who really lay into the =
keyboard as soon as they start playing really seem to like it. I view =
it as the antidote for the damage that the pervasive use of Reverse Well has=
caused.
<BR>
<BR>Steinway tuners tuning pure 5ths: This is natural to this instrume=
nt. It has a relatively high degree of inharmonicity compared to most =
other pianos. This leads naturally to a wider octave in the Temperamen=
t Sequence range, to purer 5ths and wider 3rds in this range and to virtuall=
y pure 5ths by the 5th octave and even slightly wide 5ths in the 6th and 7th=
octaves (also in the lowest octaves).
<BR>
<BR>The Steinway piano also lends itself to the so called, ET with pure 5ths=
idea. In Madison, Wisconsin, we call that the "New York Stretch". &nb=
sp;The big mistake that can be made is to try to do this with a piano which =
has lower inharmonicity or a small piano in someone's living room. At =
best, it will produce a very steely, harsh sounding piano but the usual resu=
lt is Reverse Well. Believe me, I know, I have heard it literally thou=
sands of times, here and most anywhere I have traveled.
<BR>
<BR>Bill Bremmer RPT
<BR>Madison, Wisconsin</FONT></HTML>