I echo these sentiments. I'll just throw in the notion that the piano technician, whether pro or con "extended use" of the instrument, should consider posing as an enthusiastic proponent. Ask students to come for help, and provide it graciously. I provide materials, like screws and mutes and the like, for Cage pieces. At the same time, I educate the student about proper ways to install such items so as not to damage damper felts, what kind of adhesive devices to use to mark strings or dampers (I strongly recommend "Stickie Notes" and provide them, even cut into nice little strips or squares), and various other bits of advice (EG, use a piece of sharpened brass stock in place of a chisel for "chisel on the strings. Sounds better, easier to control, won't damage anything. I provide one). As it is well enough known around the department that I even "play inside the piano" myself on occasion (Crumb's Voice of the Whale has become almost a specialty), my recommendations carry some additional weight. For instance, when I say a Steinway D isn't appropriate for such a piece, they listen. We do have policies limiting use to a couple instruments. For those who doubt the musical value of such uses of the instrument, I strongly recommend listening to Crumb's Makrokosmos (Christiane Mathe did a marvelous recording on Koch/Schwann) and Cage's Sonata's and Interludes for Prepared Piano (Boris Berman did a great complete recording - don't know what label). These are, of course, the "Classics" of the genre. And they are classics in the true sense of the word, IMO: they have real lasting power. Bottom line: we are here to serve the needs of the department/school. Being inflexible and drawing lines in the sand is counter-productive. Certainly we must be advocates for the pianos, and protect them from unnecessary damage. But we can best do this by working with, not against. End of soapbox spiel ;) Regards, Fred Sturm University of New Mexico --On Wednesday, March 3, 2004 10:22 AM -0500 "Wolfley, Eric (wolfleel)" <WOLFLEEL@UCMAIL.UC.EDU> wrote: > > > I agree with Cassie. There is a small contingent of champions of > alternative music and I see no problem with trying to accommodate them. > We keep a "sacrificial" Baldwin M available in a rehearsal room which can > be wheeled up on stage when needed for prepared pieces. This seems to be > the best method because the preparations often take a long time and the > performer needs to practice. Once the preparations are made they can > leave them in place until they have finished. The concert pianos are off > limits except for minor plucking and other inside the piano stuff which > comes up from time to time and then only with my knowledge and approval. > I find the music interesting and often intriguing. The piano is an > expressive tool for creative people and if you keep your ears and mind > open you'll often be rewarded with a musical experience. I've privately > sent Cassie and John a copy of our guidelines and am willing to share it > with anyone else who is interested. > > > > ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~ > > Eric Wolfley > > Head Piano Technician > > Cincinnati College-Conservatory of Music > > University of Cincinnati > > ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~ > > > > > > ------------------------------------------------------------------------- > --------- > > Whether or not you consider these people composers, or see a "need" for > prepared piano is not the point. The music is out there, and has been > out there for quite some time now, and I'm very interested in hearing > what other techs have come up with as far as guidelines on this matter. > I'm dealing with two teachers in this very situation right now and we're > doing our best to work together to come up with an agreeable solution. > It's very true that politics within the institution or between you and > the teacher determine how well or poorly the situation can go. Doesn't > this also depend on how much time we're personally willing/able to spend > working with the performer/piano to make sure everything goes well? > > > > Sincerely, > > Cassie Van Gelder > > > > Resident Piano Technician > > Interlochen Center for the Arts > > vangeldercj@interlochen.org > > > >
This PTG archive page provided courtesy of Moy Piano Service, LLC