[CAUT] Thanks! (PTG Convention and institute)

wimblees at aol.com wimblees at aol.com
Wed Jul 22 21:33:04 MDT 2009




3) WNG parts. We have all heard about a number of their new products in the past few months, and have all received promo materials. They are still moving ahead at a rapid pace. Coming up are shanks with adjustable knuckles: like with wippens and heels, the knuckles can be glued to fit into a range of notches to get something like 15 to 19 mm in half mm increments (buy one set and experiment, and then set it up the way you want to). Also on the horizon is a new hard bushing, of a teflon like material. They have tested it to some number of million swings and found friction to move very little, while firmness stays the same. Set in plastic flanges, humidity will obviously not be a factor. They also have sets of burnishers and reamers by .0005" (half thousandths) with lovely handles.

In my "Have Heat Gun, Will Travel" class, I heated the very thin shank on the Steinway action model to "burn" the hammer. Heating the shank for just 2  or 3 seconds made it very pliable, and I was able to turn the hammer around almost 90 degrees and back again. When the composite material cooled down, it was as stiff as before. In my second class, I went one step further. After heating it, I bent the shank about 25 degrees to the left. The shank cracked, but did not break. I then bent the shank back to straight. When it cooled, the shank was a solid as before. 

So, first of all, these shanks are not going to break under "normal" use. But when they do break, you can "
meld" them back together. I asked Kirk if I could align a wippen by heating the flange, and repositioning it under the knuckle. He said he hadn't tried it, but warned me by doing so, it might void the warrantee. :)

Wim


-----Original Message-----
From: Fred Sturm <fssturm at unm.edu>
To: caut at ptg.org
Sent: Wed, Jul 22, 2009 5:06 pm
Subject: Re: [CAUT] Thanks! (PTG Convention and institute)


I'll echo the pat on the back for the institute committee: very smoothly and efficiently run, and a great lineup My only complaint is that I was scheduled to teach opposite Andre Oorebeek, so I missed his class ;-( Can't really complain, because the institute team got to attend zero of the classes they lined up.
This convention was an especially interesting one because of some fairly radical things that were presented, things that I think we will be seeing for many years to come. A sampling:




1) Phoenix Piano Systems/Steingraeber. In short, amazing! The carbon fiber board was remarkable. The sound had elements that were different from spruce, but overall it sounded, well, like a good piano. Like a piano with extra power and carry. When you played harder, there seemed to be more of a power increase as opposed to simply voicing gradient compared to a wooden board. 

But the Phoenix System bridge termination/coupling system was the real eye opener. They had four grand pianos set up. One was a 5'8" (or so) Steingraeber with carbon board and Phoenix bridge. Next to it an identical piano, but with spr
uce board, Next to it a Steingraber concert grand in traditional setup (standard pinned bridge). And finally a rebuilt Baldwin, with the terminators going up to near the top of octave 5, standard pinned bridge above. So you could tell what difference it made very obviously. 

My verdict? Wow! Wapin on steroids. Sustain and clarity. And lots of "side effects" that go along with losing those bridge pins (like all the complaints we constantly make about them, from noises to dirty termination to false beats to tuning issues).

Bottom line, I think this is the real thing, well worth the convention just to see it. This is the invention of some Brits, at http://www.hurstwoodfarmpianos.co.uk/. I assume they will be selling/licensing the bridge system, though the website doesn't talk about that (yet, at least). Retrofit would require milling a few mms off the bridge top, so it is far more involved than a Wapin job.

BTW, this system is set up with zero downbearing (the coupling system makes downbearing unnecessary). The carbon fiber board is less than 2 mm thick. The spruce board with the Phoenix System was 4 mm thick. A wee bit revolutionary.




2) Weickert felt (a product of the Wurzen felt company licensed exclusively to Renner), debuting on the Ravenscroft piano. I think the Weickert felt is very much parallel to the Abel Natural felt, and that both of these are a real step forward. After nearly 30 years of watching the latest crazes in hammers come and go, I have become a bit jaded. But
 now I think we finally have something real. A lot of the "fads" have focused on the hammer pressing operation, from cold to hot to in between, hard to soft to medium. And results have been pretty unpredictable, at least in my limited experience.

Both Renner Weickert and Abel Natural are going back to basics of felt making. Both reject the use of acids and bleaches in processing the wool (both of which are bound to damage fibers). Both take extra care to the details of felt making: laying out the carded fibers so that the fibers are aligned (meaning layers of felt around the hammer molding, thus control of tension and compression); carefully controlled felting process so that there is extraordinary consistency in density and interlocking of fibers; control of dimension, so that the sheet has just the right taper to go into the cutting and pressing without sanding; a controlled gradient of density from bass to treble. The result is a very consistent felt, that makes a very consistent hammer. The raw sound is already quite nice, and tone gradient can be developed by a very consistent needling technique.




3) WNG parts. We have all heard about a number of their new products in the past few months, and have all received promo materials. They are still moving ahead at a rapid pace. Coming up are shanks with adjustable knuckles: like with wippens and heels, the knuckles can be glued to fit into a range of notches to get something like 15 to 19 mm in half mm increments (buy one set and20experiment, and then set it up the way you want to). Also on the horizon is a new hard bushing, of a teflon like material. They have tested it to some number of million swings and found friction to move very little, while firmness stays the same. Set in plastic flanges, humidity will obviously not be a factor. They also have sets of burnishers and reamers by .0005" (half thousandths) with lovely handles.




4) Stanwood's adjustable key ratio invention. This allows for a fulcrum to be moved under each key (all of them moved the same amount at once), somewhat on the same theory as using split felt punchings to adjust where the key pivots. The device allows for action ratio to be changed between 5:1 and 6:1 (moving the fulcra about 4-5 mm). The result is very interesting, and it confirms experimentally some thoughts that have been expressed (by myself among others) about the probable effect on tone and tonal control (due to different acceleration possibilities). 

This was installed on David's personal M&H A, with fairly light, fairly mellow hammers. In the class I attended, it was played by a couple pianists, and it was quite obvious which ratio was which just by listening. In comparison, the 5:1 sounded like a subtle muffler felt had been placed between the hammers and the strings. The higher ratio made for a more singing tone, and for more of a gradient between melody and accompaniment. This, of course, should be taken with a grain of salt, as applying to this particular setup. In a
ny case, a remarkable experiment, allowing us to hear the results of a single change that is otherwise difficult to achieve. Whether or not this turns into a widespread devise (I'm sure it will have at least a niche market), its educational uses are invaluable.




5) On a smaller scale, those who have read Oorebeek's book and watched the DVD, will have seen that sandpaper he describes as mylar backed which he used for filing hammers. I saw and read, and I went looking, and found nothing available. Jurgen of Pianoforte Supply has made it available. Expensive, but wonderful stuff (at least on first use, and I think it will hold up very, very well). It is micron graded abrasives, so you get ratings of size rather than number per area. It is an industrial product, aimed at use for machining things like crankshafts, best I have been able to figure out. Anyway, for practical, everyday use, this is something that will certainly change my life for the better. Cuts beautifully, very stable backing, so it can be controlled very well for fine results.




Lots more. Those are just a selection of things that stuck out particularly for me. The state of the piano manufacturing industry is very shaky, but the state of piano technology is seemingly in fast forward mode.





Regards,

Fred Sturm

University of New Mexico

fssturm at unm.edu









On Jul 21, 2009, at 4:40 PM, Jim Busby wrote:





All,

 

As one of the assistant directors on the inst
itute team, I want to thank everyone who taught, helped out, and/or attended the Annual Convention and Institute in Grand Rapids. Ward did a great job as director, and generally, I thought it was a very successful event. Kudos to him!

 

Being the “newbie” on the institute team I was amazed at the amount of work done “behind the scenes”. 5:30 am daily to sometimes 10:00 pm. The pedometer of one worker counted over 110 miles in those few days. As far as I know, nothing was lost, broken, or otherwise damaged. While nothing is ever perfect and we can certainly improve, I believe this convention and institute was well thought out and effectively run. Jeff Hickey, our very capable director for next year is already starting to get ready for next year! Me, I’m going on vacation for a week!

 

Thanks again.

 

Sincerely,

Jim Busby

Assistant Institute Director






= 
-------------- next part --------------
An HTML attachment was scrubbed...
URL: <http://ptg.org/pipermail/caut.php/attachments/20090722/3d63566c/attachment.htm>


More information about the CAUT mailing list

This PTG archive page provided courtesy of Moy Piano Service, LLC