[CAUT] WNG shanks - fair and balanced this time "just-o-right-o-meter"

Paul T Williams pwilliams4 at unlnotes.unl.edu
Tue Aug 24 14:53:56 MDT 2010


Hi again,

I have a brass rod I use for settling strings to bridges and worse case, 
tapping strings to bridges. 

As you may have read recently, I was having some boring issues with my new 
WNG shanks and hammers exactly the same diameter.  Well, I found a trick, 
since I don't have the correct sized reamer, I'll just describe what I did 
for a successful job..(yet to be glued)

I took the end of this brass rod (sorry no measurements at hand), but it 
was juuuust snug enough to get into the hammer, but not enough to give the 
new hammer enough "wiggle" room on the shank.  I took a file and made a 
few minor cuts into it,  so as to give it a little bite to remove ohhhh so 
slightly enough wood from the moulding while spinning it a few times to 
make a really nice fit between hammer and shank....I call it the 
"just-o-right-o-meter" (which is what I call it when putting the correct 
amount of glue before hanging.  It worked like a charm with just enough 
wiggle room between the two to get, what I'm thinking, will be a great 
glue joint with enough room to still be able to adjust the rake a tad if 
there is a problem....Like we aim for with wooden shanks, but just a bit 
less.

A few were still too tight, so I took a small round file and took off 
still a minute amount of wood from the bore hole to get it Juuuust right! 
While doing this, it amazing that either some holes or shank diameters 
were just a weee bit off to need more than the neighboring mating.  I 
could probably aim this at a small bit of difference in the swelling of 
wood, due to the time of year.  I highly doubt that the carbon fiber 
swells or contracts much if at all.

Amazing what we techs can do in a pinch without proper tools!  I will, of 
course, purchase a reamer tomorrow, but if it works, then why bother?  I 
know, it may come in handy for some other project yet unforeseen, so I'll 
still get one.

Just a thought for you dealing with these new WNG shanks.

Best,
Paul




From:
"McCoy, Alan" <amccoy at ewu.edu>
To:
"College and University Technicians <caut at ptg.org>" <caut at ptg.org>
Date:
08/24/2010 12:59 PM
Subject:
[CAUT] WNG shanks - fair and balanced this time



In the interest of fairness and accuracy I need to report back on an 
experiment regarding a statement I made yesterday about WNG shanks being 
only “one-use” shanks. I was wrong. I know many of you will be shocked to 
hear that news, but it’s true. I glued a hammer onto a WNG shank yesterday 
with Titebond Trim and Molding glue. This morning I checked it out and the 
hammer was tight as usual with a good collar. I took out my handy dandy 
heat gun and heated the joint and within 45 seconds or so off came the 
hammer and the remaining glue was soft enough for me to rub off with my 
fingers.

So there you are. Granted this takes a bit longer to remove a set of 
hammers than just cutting them off or otherwise removing them by pressing 
them out, but it is doable for those times when you might want to reuse 
the shanks. Having said that though, the shanks are definitely different 
critters and I would not advise either cutting off old hammers (with anvil 
pruners) or pressing them off. Too risky I think. In addition after you 
have glued a new set of hammers onto the shanks, don’t get out your side 
cutters and attempt to cut of the excess shank sticking out there. Not a 
good option, tempting as it may be given their small diameter. 

Alan


-- Alan McCoy, RPT
Eastern Washington University
amccoy at ewu.edu




-------------- next part --------------
An HTML attachment was scrubbed...
URL: <http://ptg.org/pipermail/caut.php/attachments/20100824/c0592cfa/attachment.htm>


More information about the CAUT mailing list

This PTG archive page provided courtesy of Moy Piano Service, LLC