David, I am dismayed that you have apparently been taken in by this obviously sham explanation of soundboard failure. There must be something in the water up there in the Vineyard or perhaps you have been losing too much sleep measuring all those actions, but your usually keen rational faculties have forsaken you here. Come on, raised grain! Those pesky little ridges will some day, soon, grow up to become soundboard cracks. I’ve seen it, you’ve seen it and most every one else has seen it. There is no denying that premature soundboard failure has been plaguing manufactures and piano rebuilders for quite some time. The problem has been spotted here in New York, in Connecticut, in Boston and overseas in the Orient. The only question is why does it happen? Here are some clues: when you compress wood more than 1% cell damage will occur. The soundboard panel is confined by the case, down bearing and , most of all by the ribs. The moisture content of the soundboard panel during the ribbing process must be carefully considered in relation to average moisture content of interior wood work in the area the piano will be living. Other consideration come into play: hydroscopic properties of adhesives, care in the panel gluing process and type and thickness of Finish. For more information contact me privately, I wrote an article for my blatantly commercial news letter “ Hartman's Fine Piano Rebuilding” on this subject. It is rather long and I don’t want to clutter the list with it. John Hartman pianocraft@aol.com
This PTG archive page provided courtesy of Moy Piano Service, LLC