I have observed that unplated brass key pins have an early corrosive coating that will wear felt FAST. If a key can be forced against a pin and moved up and down with ANY resistance bewteen key felt and pin the pin will wear the felt. It has been noted by some that very early 20th century bushings lasted longer than newer bushings. I am unable to fathume if this is the quality of felt or the effect of making felt from wool. The pins seem to oxidated as any others, but the felt just glided up and down the pin with little resistance. The only soultion I have come up with are clean, polished and lubricated pins, first quality felt, careful rebushing and fitting and lubricating. Protek is a new material that I am trying but I have no real results to date. I HATE loose keys and have been trying things for nearly 30 years, even to polishing and lubricating new pianos going into high wear situations with really superior results from doing so. Have a nice weekend, Don. Newton etc.
This PTG archive page provided courtesy of Moy Piano Service, LLC