Avery: I've probably installed 50 or 60 sets of these wippens in the last several years, and have found them to be very reliable , EXCEPT for a few sets 4-5 years ago that had wandering center pins that don't seem to want to stay put. They do seem to squeak or rattle a bit more,but no pianist has ever complained about it. Expect to have to do a little more flange screw retightening than with S&S parts, but the extra adjustability of the spring makes up for the little bit of other extra work. They are also very consistent, although the last set of factory wippens I used (3 years ago) was also much better than in the past. The Renner wippens also cost a bit less, which helps the school budget. David Graham Northern Illinois University
This PTG archive page provided courtesy of Moy Piano Service, LLC