Unless you intend to rebuild the piano with the original pinblock, use the liquid pin tightener. It often works well, does not change the geometry of the string, you won't need to completely pitch and tune the piano again. I am getting years of workable stability from Quickset in dozens of pianos, and since I always put in new pinblocks when rebuilding, I have no qualms about using pin tightener. A new application that works wonders also is the thin CA glue, super glue. It's amazing. I'm still following some recent applications of it, I think this may be better yet. I do occasionally drive in an old upright pin when loose, because it's easier than tilting the whole piano. If, however the looseness is more universal, tilt and treat, that's easier. Make sure you have a 'one man tilter', the leverage built in them handles the top heavy weight very well. Any other method is risky to life, limb, and property. The next resort is upsizing the tuning pin. I keep a supply for that purpose. But, dropping stress on a string destabilizes it, and you'll have to plan on a return visit to touch up the tuning, (or just felt it out until the next tuning . . . . ) Roger Hayden, RPT
This PTG archive page provided courtesy of Moy Piano Service, LLC