> Looking for a simpler solution to give this piano what it wants. > Many of these smaller pianos don't cooperate. When it comes to many of those pianos there is no acceptable compromise. If you use one standard it sound horrible and if you use another standard it sound terrible. You are caught between a rock and a hard place. You do what you can and hope the customer is so used to the piano they don't notice. That being said, yes the bass is stretched downward and there are the following tests to evaluate for a best solution. First the fifth (lower note to a fifth above) should be as pure as you can make it. Listen to the octave and to the double octave when you have it. Comparing the minor third to the invert major sixth the major third should be slower be about one beat per second. Example: C2 - D#2 and D#2 - C3. The difference reflects the degree of stretch. Decreasing sixth or tenths help find notes that need to be checked or compromised. Listen to the octaves. EDTs can only tell part of the story, the ears can detect the whole story when educated. Newton
This PTG archive page provided courtesy of Moy Piano Service, LLC