I suppose if you had to "warn" about the "problems" with HT's, then you'd also have to say, "I'm tuning your piano in ET. Just so you know, it will remove any key colors from the piano." Also, you'd have to tell them how much stretch you plan to use. If I remember correctly, Jorgensen discusses what piano tuning was like the days of yore. Apparently "tuning by ear" meant playing intervals one note after the other note, not both notes together. A good piano tuner would have memorized how these intervals were supposed to sound. Obviously, we're more scientific about it today, but there's still the "art" of it, such that two excellent tuners will have different styles. Regarding the artistic aspect of tuning, I wouldn't expect full disclosure. For example, when I buy a ticket to see Pollini play, I don't need to know ahead of time how fast he's going to play the second movement. If I don't like it, I'll choose another artist the next time. Now, if a customer is expecting a non-restrictive temperament and you tune it in meantone, I guess that's a different story. :) Charles
This PTG archive page provided courtesy of Moy Piano Service, LLC