Rebuilding for Performance or Show? changes - Isaac OLEG's list

[Joseph Garrett]

Isaac,
In some cases, one can retain the original damping material, (felt).
However, a proper RESTORATION allows replacement, but only with similar
materials. Sometimes it is more difficult to find something like the
original materials, but it can and should be done. The reason is that the
over-all sound of the piano will drastically change if the damping system is
modernized IN ANY WAY. When replacing strings, one cannot be exacting in the
placement of the new strings, (as opposed to the placement of the olde
strings), So.....it is necessary to use new, exact replacement material. If
any "modern" type felt is used, you have lost the original "Sound". IMO,
performance be damned. Most "performers" have less of an idea what the piano
sounded like, than we do. (AND....to be sure we are guessing, albeit an
educated guess.<G>)
I hope this is clear, for you. If one cannot try to reproduce the
originality of the instrument, then it is my opinion, that the tech should
leave it to someone who can. OR....leave it alone.
Best Regards,
Joe Garrett, RPT, (Oregon)

Been There, Didn't Like It, So I'm Here To Stay! [G}