interesting subject/sound quality

Farrell mfarrel2@tampabay.rr.com
Mon, 15 Dec 2003 11:18:07 -0500


This is a multi-part message in MIME format.

---------------------- multipart/alternative attachment
Nigel Kennedy owns and plays a 1736 Guarneri violin. I saw him play a =
bunch of Bach on this violin. I'm no violin expert, but it did indeed =
sound very sweet.

>From http://www.nigelkennedy.com/ & click on "Kennedy's violins".

"The Cathedrale", the Stradivarius Nigel used to play, wasn't his, but =
fortunately, by the time he really wanted a violin of his own, somewhere =
in the States this other violin popped up ......=20
"The American fiddle proved to be a Guarneri. These violins are not as =
much publicised, but even more exciting. Giuseppe Guarneri del Gesu was =
a contemporary of Stradivari and created his beautiful pieces in =
Cremona, Italy. The choice between these two distinguished maker is a =
matter of personal taste but most of the players I admire have found it =
necessary to move on to a Guarneri: Heifetz, Stern, Kreisler and =
Zukermann all belong to the Guarneri club. This particular example, the =
Lafont, was called after its first owner in 1736 and was considered good =
enough to take on Paganini in a playing contest, which Lafont lost but =
which caused Paganini to claim that the Lafont's sound quality was =
superior to his own. In 1880 it came into the hands of Adolf Brodsky, =
and has the distinction of being used by Brodsky on 4 December 1881 to =
premiere Tchaikovsky's great violin concerto. This particular violin was =
apparantly fabulous and, somehow, pressure was brought to bear and it =
was flown to my Oslo concert in 1990. It was everything they had said =
and more - the tone qualities were astonishing and it sounded far more =
sophisticated. It was even a slimmer instrument than the Strad, and felt =
more comfortable. The trouble was that it was even more than the Strad! =
Grief on grief: having heard just how much better the Guarneri sounded, =
the Cathedrale was never going to feel more than second best.=20
In a fast-moving chain of events literally unimaginable a year before, I =
bought the Strad and immediately traded it towards the Guarneri. It was =
a supreme moment for me: simce I was five years old I had been playing =
violin, I had struggled and achieved most of the conventional =
highpoints, and yet it took until that moment to be able to curl my =
fingers around the neck of a top-quality fiddle and call it mine."=20

I'll refrain from commenting on the Steinway remark.    ;-)

Let's just say I don't find it overly surprising that there might be =
another violin or two out there that is on a similar level or even =
preferred by some violinists other than the one that happens to be the =
household name violin. Perhaps there are some parallels in the violin =
and piano world? I wonder if there is any common bloodline among the =
marketing directors of Steinway and Stradivarius? (Oops, did I just =
comment? Nope, that was a question. Whew!)

Terry Farrell

> Wondering if anyone out there has been fortunate enough to have heard
> a Strad. live, and close-up, and could describe the differences in =
sound
> quality. Some
> years ago while I was watching Johnny Carson, he had a young fellow,
> virtuoso,
> violinist perform on his show. When sitting with Johnny, the Strad.
> subject came up.
> He didn't play one himself and suggested that not all great violinists
> preferred a
> Strad; but some other fine violin. I was quite taken aback at this,
> because I assumed
> that it would be preferred by all great musicians.=20

Carl / Winnipeg.

---------------------- multipart/alternative attachment
An HTML attachment was scrubbed...
URL: https://www.moypiano.com/ptg/pianotech.php/attachments/18/07/c8/89/attachment.htm

---------------------- multipart/alternative attachment--



This PTG archive page provided courtesy of Moy Piano Service, LLC