Hi Clyde, Rather than the repair clips, it is much better to use the repair flange. It is more trouble to put in, but does a superior job. Sometimes the customer cannot afford, a full rail replacement. Regards, John M. Ross Windsor, Nova Scotia, Canada jrpiano@win.eastlink.ca ----- Original Message ----- From: "Clyde Hollinger" <cedel@supernet.com> To: "Pianotech" <pianotech@ptg.org> Sent: Tuesday, June 03, 2003 7:44 AM Subject: Re: Billings Flanges = Brass Rail > Keith and all, > > Well, I guess what I meant is that in the repairs I did using brass rail > repair clips, the permanence of the repair was unpredictable, > particularly when there wasn't much of a stub left to work with. And > there is the possibility that I didn't do it right. These clips come > with no instructions, but the hammer wouldn't stay put, and I had to keep > doing callbacks to space the hammer because it would hang up on a > neighbor. I hate doing any kind of work that I can't guarantee. > > Another factor to consider is this. If one brass rail tooth breaks, how > long will it be until another one goes? My opinion is to either fix the > problem correctly with a whole new rail (and I agree there may be a few > pianos where this is reasonable), or ditch the piano. Unfortunately, my > opinions are not always smart, although I like to think they are. <G> > > Regards, > Clyde > > Keith McGavern wrote: > > > At 8:48 PM -0400 6/2/03, Clyde Hollinger wrote: > > >I agree with Terry. These cheap repairs sometimes work and > > >sometimes they don't. ... > > > > Clyde, > > > > I'm certain you mean well, but these repairs are far from cheap, as I > > am interpreting your connotation to mean "of decidedly inferior > > quality", which they aren't, and not cheap as in "low in price", > > which they are. > > > > When performed correctly, these inexpensive repair items work just > > fine and do offer the chance to save an instrument from being > > discarded, as you have suggested to Terry F. these people do by > > replacing their current piano with another. > > > > The repair type brass devices are ingenious in their purpose and > > design, and are invaluable in the piano service repair business when > > needed. > > > > Please know that there can come a time when there are more of the > > flanges to repair than might be deemed reasonable or cost efficient, > > but that time becomes a judgement factor for the piano technician > > and/or customer to make. > > > > A fellow named Earl Penisten, my Dad, Clair McGavern and I have taken > > care of a one hundred year old Packard Upright for four decades of > > its life that is in exquisite shape for its age, and it is definitely > > worth repairing with the brass repair parts when that time comes. The > > customer, deceased as of 2001, bought the piano directly from Packard > > in 1905. I have yet to learn of its new whereabouts. > > > > Keith McGavern > > _______________________________________________ > pianotech list info: https://www.moypiano.com/resources/#archives >
This PTG archive page provided courtesy of Moy Piano Service, LLC