Phillip Ford wrote: > > > >Thanks for bringing this up, it's another reason to be suspicious of > >the benefits of precision static calibration. It strikes me as > >absurd ...Oh, I forgot, they should only play very softly. > > > >John Hartman RPT > > I couldn't agree more. And now that you mention it, no temperament > results in all the intervals being pure. So it strikes me as absurd > that anyone bothers tuning the d_____ things at all. They're just > going to be mostly out of tune anyway when you get done. > > Phil Ford BFD Quite so Phil, but you have to understand that there is in important distinction between tuning intervals from a static point of view, and tuning them from a dynamic point of view. You see it really doesnt matter whether or not the mundane and oversimplified reduction of tuning to theoretical cents offsets conforms or not to the actual tuning. No no no no... there is a quality of in-tunedness, a resonant emphosiasm of correctness that transcends all this one dimensional thinking. When the piano is played, it must respond in kind... it must tickle when tickled, laugh when laughed at, scower when scowered to, abase when it is abased in self, and on those rare occasions when the pianist is up to it... it carry us off to places of delight and wonder not otherwise accessable to human kind. (well.. some southern California coast folks seem have taken up permant residence in these places.... but thats another story) Only tuning from a perspective of the dynamics of the pianos voice will achieve this, where as simply aligning the notes to some number on a chart will result in a voice no-one will remember. A dull, characterless, monotony of de-symphonized noise. Nay.... our task is to take that succulent breath of musical endeavour and impart this through our extremties with a creative transparency equal in quality to that used by the pianist herself. A tuners task is one of near ultimate consumation, to emulsify oneself in the veritable soul of the instrument and in leave it in a state of shimmering bliss so that the slightest touch... the most delicate contact brings it cause to sweep these sonorous soundings through the spirit of all who would but open their ears to the pianists mind. I have these devices for stiffening strings that dramatically increase string compliance..... :) Cheers RicB -- Richard Brekne RPT, N.P.T.F. UiB, Bergen, Norway mailto:rbrekne@broadpark.no http://home.broadpark.no/~rbrekne/ricmain.html http://www.hf.uib.no/grieg/personer/cv_RB.html
This PTG archive page provided courtesy of Moy Piano Service, LLC