André, >English is not my native language and I am not a >wood expert I want to ask you what you have >against rock maple. I have nothing against maple for many uses in piano manufacture, but I believe there are more suitable woods for hammer cores. >Steinway Hamburg has maple these days for their >hammer moldings and we do many hammer changes >with these maple hammers. Yes I am aware that they are using maple, but I haven't played any of these instruments yet. I also understand that the current Ds have lighter hammers than previously, so the felt must be considerably lighter since the core wood is heavier. >I must say I like these hammers but I like them >especially because they have a fine quality >Wurzen felt. It is possible that a more resilient felt might allow for a respectable tone from maple cores, but my preference has been for hammers with cores of Walnut or Mahogany, on account of their lighter density. >My ears are ok and I trust my musicality I don't doubt you. >Does Steinway Hamburg use a different kind of maple? It is possible that Steinway are not using rock maple for their hammer cores. They might be using European maple, otherwise known as Sycamore, botanical name Acer pseudoplatanus. Visually, these two timbers look almost identical, but Sycamore has a lighter density (0.6 gr/cc) than rock maple (0.7 gr/cc). >I highly value your experience and would >appreciate it if you could tell us what you have >against rock maple. My early experience with Hormbeam cored Imadagawa hammers put me off using hard core wood for hammer cores. You could voice these things forever and they still screamed at you, similar to the early series Kawai KG hammers. I understand that hammer manufacturers have to be very careful when pressing up hammers made with lighter cores such as Walnut or Mahogany. I suspect that when using maple (or hornbeam) cores, it is possible to load them up to the max. in the press without fear of damaging the core-wood. Furthermore, you can imagine how much compressional pressure there must be right at the apex of the core. A softer core wood provides for for a level of 'give' under the highly compressed hammer felt. This may go some way towards explaining why hammers with maple or hormbeam cores are generally so bright. Ron O. -- OVERS PIANOS Grand piano manufacturers ________________________ Web: http://www.overspianos.com.au Email: mailto:ron@overspianos.com.au ________________________
This PTG archive page provided courtesy of Moy Piano Service, LLC