Keith, Stéphane, Avery I find my self in agreement with all of you, tho there is some apparent dissagreement between you. The thing is, a good tech should of course be able to handle the very best of instruments, be it Kawaii, Steinway, Overs, Steingræber, Fabulioli :)... what have you. That many RPT's and their counterparts from various associations around the world are obviously not quite ready to fully assure top performance of these instruments says more about the level of expertise required by our associations, and the degree we succesfully impress upon our members of the need to stay humble in the face of aquiring new and refined skills in our chosen trade. Seems clear to me that a freshly baked RPT more often then not should think twice about whipping out the needle and assuming he/she is capable of imparting high quality voicing to such an instrument. No doubt that is the concern felt by these same companies, many of which run their own academies.... or shall we call them finishing schools for experienced techs. Ideally, factories and associations should work together to establish different levels of acreditation that fairly reflect a techs abilities, and that all techs in all associations respect fully their own level of acheivement, and that of those who have progressed further. Seems to me there is really plenty of work around for all, and plenty of opportunity for each tech to reach the highest levels of achievement. So knowing your place at any given time shouldnt be nearly the problem it generally is. So.. I end up agreeing with Stephane that any compentent tech should be able to handle these instruments, while also agreeing with Avery and Keith in that just because you are an RPT... doesnt mean you should take on one of these high quality high performance instruments. Cheers RicB
This PTG archive page provided courtesy of Moy Piano Service, LLC