Hi there David. I personally dont have a problem with manufacturers bringing out or holding onto old designs as long as they insure good quality control. But then I tend to value an instrument from the standpoint of how well the manufacturer accomplished what they set out to do in contrast too questioning whether the manufacturer could have come up with a better design. I've always thought there was so much diversity that just about anyones tastes should be pretty well covered in some fashion or another, and that there is never a lack of builders who want to carve out their own path... new designs have seemed aplenty to me. One could perhaps reverse your querrie and wonder why the asians are always trying some new designs and being thankfull for the conservation of the tried, true, and trustworthy. Change is good... so is holding on to what has been. Actually, I wonder why the old square idea isnt revived...especially the early 1800's vintage. These instruments were ofte times origionally meant for a similar market as todays verticals, and I dare say that in todays world they would quite possibly have some decided advantages over them. Cheers RicB
This PTG archive page provided courtesy of Moy Piano Service, LLC