David Ilvedson/SAT Tuning Test Scores

[David Ilvedson]

This is a multi-part message in MIME format.

---------------------- multipart/alternative attachment

But Terry, what do you think the Master tuning on that Winter spinet wo=
uld sound like?   Not a pretty sight...it IS possible that the SAT coul=
dn't handle the compromises needed between the tenor/bass that the aura=
l tuning come up with.   
David I.




Original message
From: Farrell 
To: Pianotech 
Received: 9/13/2005 3:42:37 PM
Subject: Re: David Ilvedson/SAT Tuning Test Scores


Well, expiriment will tell, but my guess is that a strict FAC tuning on=
 a winter spinet will not pass the PTG exam - especially in the low ten=
or and bass.
 
Terry Farrell


----- Original Message ----- 

Read my post..."good piano" ...but if 3 tuners were to aurally Master T=
une that Winter....hee, hee, hee...the SAT could duplicate it within th=
e test periameters.
Again...you can't pass the PTG test without tuning a 2 octave section a=
urally, which is why we don't have ETDs hanging a shingle out...;-]
David I.




Original message
From: Farrell 
To: "Pia
Received: 9/13/2005 1:29:51 AM
Subject: Re: David Ilvedson/SAT Tuning Test Scores


Always? NO WAY! On a good piano? Probably. On a large, well-scaled pian=
o? Sure.
 
If you can tune a Winter spinet with an FAC tuning and pass the tuning =
exam, then the tuning exam tolerances need to be tightened!
 
Terry Farrell
----- Original Message ----- 
From: David Ilvedson 

I would find it hard to believe that a FAC tuning on a good piano would=
n't pass the PTG test with flying colors...but I will check with some t=
uning examiners...I'm sure we have some on the List...am I as preposter=
ous as Joe says?
David I.


Original message


David Ilvedson said: "Somewhat lack it may be but SAT III will always g=
et a 100% score on PTG=3D
 tuning test...not too bad a place to begin.  Not the stability part of=
=3D
 the test though...that's the tuner totally..."

David,
Where, pray tell, did you glean that Preposterous Idea! Not even! Check=
 with Tuning Examiners, before you make such a wild claim! Please?<G>
Joe Garrett, R.P.T.
Captain, Tool Police
Squares R I

---------------------- multipart/alternative attachment
An HTML attachment was scrubbed...
URL: https://www.moypiano.com/ptg/pianotech.php/attachments/d5/38/56/7e/attachment.htm

---------------------- multipart/alternative attachment--