[pianotech] Clarification Question: i'll take a pass

Ron Nossaman rnossaman at cox.net
Sun Aug 30 17:22:25 MDT 2009


Dean May wrote:

> You are correct, Ron, that numbers like that do present problems for tuning
> stability. But that isn't really what the discussion between us has been
> about. You refuse to acknowledge that a/c air coming out of the vent is at a
> very high RH. Even here you forcefully assert that it makes no difference
> where the vent is in relation to the piano. 

I don't refuse to acknowledge it at all. Air chilled to the 
dew point will HAVE to have a very high RH% if chilling it 
produced any moisture runoff. I've been unsuccessfully trying 
to point out to you that RH% is NOT the same as MC, and 
raising the RH% by chilling does NOT increase the absolute 
moisture content of air. The fact that the A/C is producing 
water proves that the air coming out has a lower moisture 
content than the air going in. That's it.


> One of the pianos I previously spoke of encountering with the a/c blowing on
> it had a full dampchaser system with a back cover. Yet it was still going
> substantially sharp. If I am to take your advice then, the a/c vent blowing
> on it is of no consideration. 

I won't chase details with you based on a false premise, but I 
don't advocate either a heating or cooling duct dumping 
directly into a piano, whatever the RH%, and never have. Any 
more words you'd like to put into my mouth, or can we get 
reasonable about this?
Ron N


More information about the pianotech mailing list

This PTG archive page provided courtesy of Moy Piano Service, LLC