Israel Stein wrote: > Now, with modern piano wire 3-4 coils take up very roughly 1/4" on the > tuning pin. That's about how much wire (at a minimum) you have to wind > over a hole-less pin to keep it all in place (of course, much thinner > wire, a lot more coils). So when the "pin with a hole" came into use, > they just kept winding as much wire on it as "looked right" without > thinking about whether or not it was really necessary. (By the way, > anyone know when the "pin with a hole" got invented?) This may be a > total fantasy - but it sounds plausible. Aw man, It pains me to consider that this may be the case, but it's (reluctantly) not unreasonable. Leaves a really funky residue in the conceptual wing though. Ick. Don't know about the pin with the hole. Jack was there, let's ask him Ron N
This PTG archive page provided courtesy of Moy Piano Service, LLC