Hi Fred, It is possible to change the SATll program numbers of a FAC tuning and not know that they have been changed. Only a hard copy will verify the correct numbers. I know this to be a fact because a few years back when I was using the canned tuning programs and using the offset to a different pitch, several of the programs that were being used a lot suddenly were not giving a smoth progression and had to be reprogramed. I have not noticed this with the SATlll as I always take new FAC readings and do not use the canned programs. Also the DO function is available to change the program sharper or flatter. Joe Goss imatunr@srvinet.com www.mothergoosetools.com ----- Original Message ----- From: "Avery Todd" <atodd@UH.EDU> To: <caut@ptg.org> Sent: Thursday, January 10, 2002 11:34 AM Subject: Re: CTE-Master Tuning > Fred, > > I think what people are talking about is that with humidity changes, the > piano can change, thereby affecting the FAC numbers, thereby affecting > the "Master Tuning", in this case. This has been being talked about > lately on the pianotech list about the climate changes changing the FAC > numbers somewhat. > > I suppose it's "possible" for the SAT to drift, I don't really know. I > just noticed that I didn't have the smooth progression of thirds in the > temperament that I always strive for. That's what got me started checking > things. > > Thanks for the post. > > Avery > > >This notion that the SAT "adjusts" tunings without being told to is, I > >think, apocryphal. It is not an "active" machine. What's in memory is > >simply in memory. The calculating function only happens when you > >activate it, with some difficulty (sequences of key pushes that are > >unlikely to happen by accident). > > I guess it might be possible that some electronic/media corruption > >could happen over time. If that should be the case, there's an easy way > >to check whether the numbers in the memory have changed. You should have > >a hard copy of the master tuning somewhere. Scroll through what's > >recorded on the SAT and see if the numbers are the same as the hard > >copy. > > With respect to making any changes in a master tuning, definitely do it > >by committee. > >Fred Sturm > >University of New Mexico > > > >Dennis Johnson wrote: > >> > >> I remember listening to a discussion with Sanderson about the fact that > >> sometimes the SAT can make small adjustments to a particular memory > >> over time if it is not used regularly. Something about the machine > >> calculating what it perceives to be a "correction", based relatively on > >> the other numbers. For whatever the reason, we are not recommended to use > >> master tunings we store in memory for long periods. They should be redone > >> every year even if using the same piano. Just copy it, fix it, then record > >> it again. > >> > >> ______________________ > >> ______________________ > >> > >> Dennis Johnson > >> Piano Technician > >> St. Olaf College > >> Northfield, MN. 55057 > >> (507) 646-3587 shop > >> (507) 646-3527 fax > >> (612) 529-6123 home
This PTG archive page provided courtesy of Moy Piano Service, LLC