Bluthner action; "big question"

[Mark Cramer]

Whats the general type question here ?

RicB


In spare time I rebuild grands for resale. I'm typically looking for
instruments (not necessarily big name brands) of good original quality, in
the 6' to 7' range that require total restoration.

As possible, I attempt to process every instrument the same; hand-rubbed,
satin-ebony finish, all appearance details restored to appear new, and full
renovation of the instrument to perform as new.

The idea being; if a client likes an instrument that's already sold, the
next one will have a predictably similiar appeal.

I know we all have different philosophies on restoration... this is mine,
and I'm very proud of the resulting instruments.

The question, crass as it may seem, is whether I can gain full return on a
major restoration of a two-pedal piano with an historic action?

Those of you who have a "handle" on resale of restorations can probably tell
me;

"in your market would this instrument complete, trade similar to a likewise
restored Mason or Knabe?"

On the other hand, I really like the modern Bluthners (80's?) we have at
Banff. My intent, if it were practical, was simply to do a full
action-replacement (along with full belly-work), such that I wasn't
handicapping resale potential of the instrument.

So there you have it:

1. If the piano could be resold for top value, I'm willing to look at the
authentic/historic route.

2. If it could easily be modernized (new stack over existing keys/frame for
instance) I would
have to look at that... (and deal with your consternation later). :>)

3. If neither of the above are true, then I guess I should just buy it and
Fed-ex it down to Ed.

As colleagues, you are always most helpful, and I trust your opinions. Now,
like on the price is right, "do I bid or pass?!"

thanks,

Mark Cramer,
Brandon University