Hi Keith
Ok, now I see where you are comming from. You simply say the output arm
is the jack pin and therefore a fixed length, and further the jacks
angle supporting whatever load is on it doesnt really figure into the
equation.
I think its fair to say the huge majority of things written up to now on
the subject of the whippen disagrees. Fair enough...they may in the end
be wrong and you right. I believe tho there are a couple points you are
overlooking that I dont think you correctly can overlook. One, the
position of the output load vs the output arm support point are changed
relative to each other. Whether you think in terms of the jack top or
the jack pin... this still effectively changes the ratio in the sense
Jon points to... i.e. lengthening the output arm. Its just that you
transfer the responsibility for the change to the hammer shank. The
other is that I am unconvinced you can get away with discounting the
jacks angle as you do.
Still, its an interesting idea and it will be fun to look at closer with
action models. One quick experiment would be to chop off the rep lever
and fashion the rep spring so that it still works the jack return. Then
adjust jack angle and reposition the hammer shank so the knuckle matches
instead of the usual other way around. That way one could use BW
measurements to look a bit closer at whether the angle of the jack
itself actually does make a diff. Even tho BW measurements are rather
iffy things ... it might be illustrative.
Cheers
RicB
On 11/1/07, Richard Brekne <ricb at pianostemmer.no> wrote:
>
> Either way moving
> the whole whippen 2 mm moves both points 2 mm.
This is where I think you are missing it. The jack center to wippen
center
cannot change in distance. The RA remains the same length. 1 to
1.477changes to 1 to
1.430 with a 2mm rail move on the S&S wippen I just measured. It
can lift
more weight. Not much but some.
If you lean the post or the jack from the tangent line of the RA,
you have
to use vector analysis and angular momentum formulas to figure the
output
transfered to the jack. It is not a distance measurment factored back
directly against the EA. As the jack leans it is an exponential function
based on the number of degrees the jack rotates. In other words from
0* to
30* there is not much change in force then from 30 to 60* it decreases
rapidily and from 60* to 90* force is about 0.
As it is I have a lot more to think about and detail, thank you and
I will
get back as soon as I can.
Keith
This PTG archive page provided courtesy of Moy Piano Service, LLC