Hi Ed
Yes, I've been following that with interest, tho my understanding is
that Anne takes a more museum restorations perspective with these
things. In my Bluthner project I found it particularly difficult to get
any real help. For a variety of reasons. Some folks are just plain
protective of course... I guess the industry has always had to deal with
that. Some wanted me to approach the project from a completely
different angle then I had in mind.
In the end, it came out quite nice in itself... tho I lack enough
acoustic references to know yet if I have succeeded in my goal of
reproducing the basic sound character of the instrument while bringing
the upper treble more in line with modern sound. This second goal is a
loaded matter really. Because through the some 3 odd years I have spent
so far on the thing, I've found that perceptions about what the "snuff
it was made for" vary quite wildly.
Some say for example that the sustain and body of these old instruments
were actually quite similar to todays instruments after all... and this
was possible because of the completely different string materials used.
Shorter lengths for high treble strings were not a problem for this
reason and we are left forced to re-scale and use presently available
string materials to come close. Pure sound is said by many to be a
blessing in this regard and certainly performs well on my Bluthner.
I most certainly will approach the Pleyel differently then I did the
Bluthner. The Pleyel will be sold to a pianist friend of mine who loves
these old instruments pretty much as they are. So this will pretty much
just be stabilized with no major parts being replaced. Epoxy
stabilization of the pinblock is in my mind a perfectly ok way to
proceed as in the end if one ends up someday having to replace the
pinblock one has done no "damage" in the meantime.
Thanks to my good friend Linda from Sweden for the link and for her
enthusiastic post.
Cheers
RicB
The Journal is running an extended series on understanding and
restoring
19th century pianos.
Conservators have special techniques for working on pianos like
this, and
they are going to share some of them with us.
Epoxy consolidation of a pinblock, for example, is much easier than
removing
and replacing a mortised block.
I hope you will wait a few months to learn about this.
It is helpful, in fact crucial to develop a collegial relationship with
someone who specializes in dealing with
"pre-modern" instruments. The "snuff" you try to bring it up to
should be
the "snuff" it was made for.
Note, for example, the description of the sustain on Chopin's piano
in the
Times link from Linda Strahle. In her articles on 18th and 19th
century
pianos Anne Acker has given descriptions of the relationship between
the
sound of historic instruments and the interpretation of music
written for
those pianos.
Ed Sutton
This PTG archive page provided courtesy of Moy Piano Service, LLC