Hi Ed.
I agree totally with your points about action re-design using Stanwood
principles. I have made similar comment several times. I find his
methods absolutely superb for balancing an existing system, and highly
recommend the full 9 yards when it comes to that bit. But I choose to
look at any redesign of the actions ratio from the actions geometric
perspective. There is a lot going on besides just weight. The speed of
parts seems always to be totally overlooked in ratio discussions. I also
agree with your points about variety in actions... tho I must confess
for most jobs I opt for a set of top medium SW curve hammers if the
ratio is low enough.
Still, I'm very interested in the whole variety of belly and scaling
perspectives available from history. Everyone today seems to opt for a
grain direction that goes very close to parallel to the bridge, with the
basic idea of the ribs being the support for downbearing in some sense
or another...and hence needing to themselves be alligned more or less
perpendicular to the bridge. There has been almost no discussion of how
alignment of these can affect stiffness to mass ratio and how that can
in turn be used to approach different tonal desires in different parts
of the scale. Taking that a few large steps further.... I want very
much to understand better how much more radical grain directions were
meant to function...what they were after, what reservations and
compromises they were forced to face. Perhaps there is some worth
following some of these early lines of thinking further down their
respective roads.
One thing that goes again and again in these earlier instruments. They
were not meant to be hugely loud affairs. Instruments were often meant
to be far more ... well.. portable in a sense. By that I mean that you
would expect a piano concert to be in a very intimate setting with a
room in which allowed for a much different kind of instrument then the
modern grand for the music being played.
Cheers
RicB
Hi Ric,
I'll just reiterate a bit of the point I was trying to make: it
isn't
just the difference in sound produced by the belly and scaling
(though that
is very important). It is also the difference in response felt by the
pianist. I find certain tendencies of many who do "action re-design"
following "Stanwood principles" rather disturbing. There is often a
knee-jerk decision to go for, say, a "5.5 action ratio," with a
corresponding decision to go for fairly heavy hammers. The heavy
hammers are
chosen because of a prejudice towards "wanting more fundamental" or
something of that sort, and then the ratio tags along since
otherwise you
will have too much mass and corresponding inertia. Result: an even
vanilla
spectrum of pianos, rather than the variety that used to be so
inspiring.
I am very much in favor of having an array of hammer weight and
action
ratio to choose from. I suppose some will say that has to be matched
to the
belly and scaling, and probably they are at least somewhat correct.
Though I
understand that early (late 19th century) Steinway had heavy board and
scaling with much lighter hammers than today. I don't think there is
anywhere near a complete understanding of the interactions of all these
things.
At any rate, I am just speaking up for retaining, or at least
considering retaining, high action ratio where it is found. Which
does, of
course, mean matching hammer mass to make it work.
And you say the customer pretty much wants it the way it is, so this
"advice" isn't going to make any difference. But I thought I'd air
the ideas
a bit anyway.
Regards,
Fred Sturm
University of New Mexico
This PTG archive page provided courtesy of Moy Piano Service, LLC