I too had the same advice of lowering the tension first, strings still broke, not many but at least one each season. It¹s been three years now. Firtunately, this B is not used much. Richard On 5/10/10 9:27 AM, "Adkins, Richard" <radkins at coe.edu> wrote: > Friends, > > I used it on an L according to the scale provided two years ago. > > The tone was sweeter, if not as strong, and the attack was really nice. The > best attack > I've heard from strings. This might be because they are softer wire. > > I only had one string break at the hitch pin, which I replaced and the > others held, UNTIL this year, second term, when they began breaking from about > A4 up through C6 I believe. > > Mostly the 16.5, 16s, but I did have some 15 1/2s, 17s, and an 18 break too. > > I reported this to Carlos, the developer, and he called me from Amsterdam to > discuss this. > We spoke at some length. Needless to say, he was very upset to hear this. > > He claims that the string is softer and tends to wrap around the bearing > points, so you > must first lower tension (back off) before tuning. He says that since he's > altered his approach > to tuning the pure sound wire he's not had any breaking strings. > > Try it and see,I'm going to. He kindly sent me replacement wire at his expense > for my trouble. > > I have replaced most of the pure sound wire w/Mapes. > > I agree, I regularly tune pianos with strings atleast 50 if not 100 years old > that have not broken in all that time! > > I wanted to stainless steel wire to eliminate the rust problem. Well, I > probably > did eliminate the rust problem with it, but got a breakage problem instead. > > When you install the wire, you must wind the coils slowly, and also make your > hitch > ends slowly. He advises that you put some lube on the hitch pins, and perhaps > a pin point > at the agraffes or bridge pins. I had lubed the hitch pins, but not the bridge > or agraffes. > You can also lube the capo on the non speaking side, and any bearing points > between > the tuning pin and the capo. This "should" minimize breaking. > > I don't mind replacing one or two occassionaly, but whole sections are just > too much. > > Juan says this wire/scaling was made for pianos with a very "short scale". I > don't > know what kind of scale the B has. > > Even the new B's sound weird at the break from note #20 and 21,22. > > It's been a great experiment, but really upset me when they began to pop left > and right, > and over night! Hope Juan's techniques will prevent any more. I won't be using > that > wire again, until I can verify the new approach works. I'd like to do a > Steinway S > that is very rusty with it. Maybe just Mapes will have to do. > > YMMV....! > > Cheers > > Richard Adkins > Coe College > > > -------------- next part -------------- An HTML attachment was scrubbed... URL: <http://ptg.org/pipermail/caut.php/attachments/20100510/0f2774a1/attachment.htm>
This PTG archive page provided courtesy of Moy Piano Service, LLC