I'm not a lawyer. My opinions and advice on the subject are in the same category of amateurism as when a lawyer tries to tune his own piano. However, I won't let that small fact stop me from voicing an opinion. Let me temper what follows by explaining that my father is a judge, and almost every other adult member of my family is a lawyer. I get to hear a lot of lawyer talk for free. Advice: Resolve the issue before a lawer is required. If that's not possible have a lawyer in court. Do not assume that the system is biased toward consumers. If anything judges are biased against people who waste their time. People without lawyers waste the judge's time. Don't waste the judge's time. Be prepared to state the case clearly and briefly. The central issue is just when and how the plate broke. Can the customer prove that it was not already broken? Good luck - Frank Weston
This PTG archive page provided courtesy of Moy Piano Service, LLC