Ok guys, you got me. But how is this possible unless the bridge pins are notched by string wear or something? (Evil spirits? Trickle down economy? Oops, sorry, same thing.) I've chased a lot of false beats without being able to verify this phenomenon, bu
t "There are more things in Heaven and Earth..." etc. I sure would find it a lot easier to believe if there were a good plausible explanation. I always have had the need to look under the rock and decide for myself. Incidentally, I have seen string dents
in removed bridge pins that could account for the thing, but that wouldn't me the case in a piano with new bridges & strings. Hmmmm...
Well, (drat!) I guess that's the WHAT. Now, who's got the WHY?
Eschew obfuscation!
Ron Nossaman
>
>> I don't think
>> it's possible for a string, with measurable positive bearing, to ride up a pin (against
>> tension), slanted to force the string down on the bridge (against side bearing), and
>> stay there until someone knocks it back down where it belongs.
>
>That's exactly what happens. We had one Steinway D that was used in
>1981 by 78% of the competitors. It was tuned and tuned and tuned
>constantly, so it was *very* stable as far as the tuning pin setting and
>string segment settling were concerned. After a hard workout, when
>some unisons had drifted (only slightly, of course [;>, but
>understandably), Pris and I found that most of the time, the strings had
>been _knocked upwards_ on the bridge pins from the heavy playing.
>Lightly tapping the string down onto the bridge put the unison back
>virtually perfectly in tune. Go figure!?!
>
<snip>
>
>Joel Rappaport
>Round Rock, Texas
>
>
>I, too, was very skeptical of this until a colleague did a demonstration at a PTG chapter
>meeting. He put a wire-handled mute between two strings in the treble and lightly tapped
>one of those strings at a 45-degree angle just in front of the bridge. The mute changed
>angle about 10 degrees. It's hard to see the string move but you can't miss what the mute
>does when the string settles!
>
>--
>Thomas A. Cole, RPT
>Santa Cruz, California
>
>
>
Ron Nossaman
This PTG archive page provided courtesy of Moy Piano Service, LLC