Hi Bill: I noticed a few people took exception to your remark about the "Final Solution." May I be so bold as to remind you of something you already know, and that is that the Owen Jorgensen "Five and Seven" Temperament was developed after the ET. So also was the Coleman IV, VII, & XI. Then contemporarily, the Bailey "Well Meant", and last but not least the special Bremmer version of the "Equal Beating Victorianized Modified Meantone". All of these post date the "Twelfth Comma Meantone system" as you so cleverly described our current Equal Temperament last summer. I take that last description seriously and therefore include ET in the HTs. I hope we don't come to the place where we have ET police, or HT police, or thought police. I couldn't help thinking of another Bill when you said "I stand by my statement." That Bill had something to hide at that time. If various HTs are to survive, it will be in the market place of Music and not in politics or polemics. Ideas forced upon people will eventually die. Witness the Crusades, Inquisitions, Nazism, Communism, etc. Jim Coleman, Sr.
This PTG archive page provided courtesy of Moy Piano Service, LLC