In a message dated 98-10-21 11:16:58 EDT, you write: << This would have been the view of piano makers in 1798 too, and the industry throughout the 19th Century. The idea of repairing an old piano at great expense would have been laughed at, just as would the idea of making a piano that was not up-to-date (such as "some" people do nowadays). Consumers wanted the best and most current newest piano they could get and mucking around with an old one would have been considered slumming, as well as being bad for the piano business. >> Stephen: With all due respect for someone who has made an art out of restoring pianos of historical significance, as you might have read at the beginning of my post, I said, "with few exceptions". Granted there are pianos that are worth restoring, just as there are cars, buildings, trains, etc, that have historical value. For those, I would make the exception. But you've got to admit, there is a lot of junk out there, that should never have been made in the first place, that deserves a decent burial. Wim
This PTG archive page provided courtesy of Moy Piano Service, LLC