Thought I would change the subject from "noisy key inserts" because the techniques are unrelated except for the problem they solve. Years ago I had a piano with really large holes for the balance rail pins, a case that looked perfect for inserts, but I had experimented with the inserts enough to know I hated them. I did this: 1 - swabbed the holes with a pipe cleaner and 5 minute epoxy, 6 or 7 keys at a time, leaving just tackiness, not a lot of glue. 2 - set them on waxed paper, dropped some coarse pine sawdust (about the size of pretzel salt) down through the top, tamping it into the hole a bit with a tiny rod, let fully cure. 3 - blew the sawdust out 4 - eased the holes - Voila! Adhering to the epoxy in the swabbed holes was a layer of grains of pine sawdust, enough that they reduced the size of the hole. Then, with a tapered key easing tool they were either squashed against the sides, or driven somewhat into the soft wood of the key, that they then provided a quiet, correctly sized, hole. I also tried this with ground pecan shells that I use in sandblasting, but did not think it worked as well. I don't do this all the time, as it is seldom necessary, but then putting in inserts should not be done on every piano! I do know it worked out very well on that, and one or two other pianos. (By the way, I bought out a shop and have four or five cutters and thousands of inserts if anyone wants to buy some, - have had them, brand new, on a shelf for years, and would not consider using them.) Bill SImon Phoenix
This PTG archive page provided courtesy of Moy Piano Service, LLC