Hi all, Thanks to everyone who replied to my last question regarding well temperament. Seeing how the last discussion remained quite civil and very informative on this subject I would like to tempt fate again with the following: In Owen Jorgensen's book Tuning the Historical Temperaments by Ear he states on page 431 "In direct opposition to equal temperament, the purpose of well temperament is to allow harmonic color-change through modulation. Only when the tones are not equally spaced can there be different effects in the various tonalities. This latter quality cannot exist in true equal temperament in which all tonalities have identical effects except for increasing or decreasing beat speeds. In the number of proportional beat triads, well temperament is superior to equal temperament and also most of the meantone temperaments. This gives well temperament a certain rhythmic harmoniousness." I was with him up until the last two sentences, then came "proportional beat triads" and "rhythmic harmoniousness." Anyone want to try and educate me on proportional beat triads and rhythmic harmoniousness? That last ones a mouth full. Doug Mahard
This PTG archive page provided courtesy of Moy Piano Service, LLC