In a message dated 3/22/2001 12:04:20 PM, Bob D. wrote: <<"I would say that of pianists who expressed a preference, I have had more prefer uniform aftertouch to uniform dip, so I lean that way unless they express an opposite preference. How about the rest of you?">> Bob; I basically agree with the aftertouch being the most desirable....there are a few caveats though :-) (the following assumes a 'normal' piano) a.)If the hammer line is straight then you can't have uniform dip 'and' uniform aftertouch. b.)If the dip is uniform you can't have uniform aftertouch 'and' a straight hammer line. c.)If the aftertouch is uniform than the hammer line won't be straight if the dip is also uniform. Given that a basic amount of movement is required of the key to function (+-) the range of dip is fairly static. What is not static is the range of aftertouch and/or hammer blow distance (sic.....hammer line). What I have found is that players who play in the fff regions seem to prefer an even dip and that everyone from ff to ppp much prefer an even aftertouch. Just my observations. Jim Bryant (FL)
This PTG archive page provided courtesy of Moy Piano Service, LLC