Jon writes inre temperament choice:
>Moore Representative Victorian
>Mild enough so as not to alarm . The next step Ed tells me is the Thomas
>Young.
Ah, yes, the Young is cerainly another step towards key character.
However, I have been receiving some input from other techs working their way
through the tunings, and it seems that a smaller step can be found between
the Moore &Co. (or Broadwood's Best) and the Young, which is a full blown
Well-temperament,(I say that because it has a third, the F#-A#, tempered by
the syntonic comma, which seems to be a historical benchmark in many of the
tuings). This smaller step can be had with the "Usual" tuner's temperament
from the Broadwood research in Owen's book.
It seems that the "usual" tuner's results were slightly less refined than
the "Best" tuner's, giving the temperament stronger contrast between keys.
Both of the Broadwood tunings are, imshl (in my somewhat haphazard logic),
efficient beginning points for the customer wishing to try a little
historical flavor to their keyboard. There are no hard fast rules, here.
That is why the tuner should become a little familiar with the tunings in
secure places before offering customers a vague recommendation.
REgards,
ED Foote
This PTG archive page provided courtesy of Moy Piano Service, LLC