Tom, I suspect that you are "over pulling" a bit too far, in order to get the string to settle. This is what I call "loading". Those of us that have been tuning a long time, have found that "loading" can be used to an advantage. It is something we all do, but controlling it can sometimes be difficult. To define loading: we pull the sting to pitch and then pull it sharp, to the point that we have to "force" it back down to JUST land on pitch. To look at it another way: Once the string is "loaded", if we flex the tuning pin with the tuning hammer, first to test how sharp and then to test how flat the string will go; the "flexing" will indicate that we have hardly any beats on one direction, whereas we have very fast beats on the other direction. This manifests itself, more so, in the extreme treble. Because of the lesser amount of tuning hammer movement, to tune in the extreme treble, we will come back to a "regular" tuning and find that our extreme treble has gone way sharp, from where we know we left it. (ETD tuners are more aware of this, I think) Best Regards, Joe Garrett, RPT, (Oregon) Been There, Didn't Like It, So I'm Here To Stay! [G}
This PTG archive page provided courtesy of Moy Piano Service, LLC