Nice article JD Tho it is really about a different related topic... it does have a directly related paragraph. As far as I can see that paragraph shows exactly what I've been saying. The section Discussion of Physical Causes outlines a general cause of false beating along the lines of the wobbly pin model. BUT then if goes on to state that for a 1 meter string at 261 herz a 0.1 mm difference in length would result in a false beat of around 1/40 th Hz ! Figure out the amount of sideways wobble required to get that 0.1 mm difference in length. And as for the 80 mm long example C88 the article has that same difference in length change (0.1 mm) The only way the horizontal and vertical string lengths can be as much as 0.1 mm different as a result of the pin moving is if the pin is moving back and forth. Sideways... it has to move too much. Otherwise... the article does raise some interesting thoughts about bridge admittance. In general the notion of a string with anisotropic localized boundary conditions at the bridge can get into several issues. The reading is a bit think for the most part and I'll need a few readings to digest it fully. Cheers RicB
This PTG archive page provided courtesy of Moy Piano Service, LLC