> If a good knurler is used and the shanks are properly knurled, there is > no problem in dry fitting them in such a way that they can be aligned > fore and aft etc. Then the expansion of the shank makes a tight fit to > the hammer bore hole, as you say. Yes, pulling the hammer back to the drill angle and away from where you had it aligned. At least that was my experience. > The problem is that few people own a good knurler, and that they are not > available through the big box suppliers. > > Jurgen Goering I think the problem is that there isn't any real problem with reaming hammers to an adjustable fit bore, and letting the glue hold them, unless you believe you can hear the difference. I've seen a number of loose hammers through the years and in every case it was a result of inadequate glue, not improper fit. With reasonable care in fitting (not super floppy sloppy) it just isn't a problem in the real world. I have a good quality shank knurler on the door frame above the pencil sharpener. I use it for upright shanks, but not for grands. Yes, I tried it on grands, but found better speed, controllability, and precision from just taper reaming the hammers for a slip fit with some adjustability. If the knurler works better for you on grands, great. Knurl away, but I still say it's not necessary to a good hammer hanging job. Ron N
This PTG archive page provided courtesy of Moy Piano Service, LLC