[pianotech] bass string twisting direction and a new query

Ron Nossaman rnossaman at cox.net
Sun Apr 26 11:12:34 PDT 2009


John Dorr wrote:

> NOW... another question or two... Why does it sometimes (not always) 
> seem to make things not change or even WORSE to twist a string?  Maybe 
> they were twisted previously and further change is no help?  Or 
> harmful?  (Yes, I twisted them before today's serendipitous moment, but 
> I twisted them BOTH ways, to check to see if either way would improve 
> sound.)

If you are considering twisting it at all, it will be because 
it's making an objectionable sound. There's no reason to 
assume twisting the string will fix anything when you don't 
know the cause of the problem, so you're already guessing. So 
try it, and when it doesn't do what you need, replace it.


> Second question:  if twisting from the loop end, which I imagine is what 
> everybody does on an OLD string you're trying to improve, shouldn't you 
> go in whole turns rather than half turns?  Seems like half turns change 
> the bends in the wire through the bridge pins.  Or is my thinkin' 
> stinkin' there?

You're talking about forcing a junk string above an 
arbitrarily minimum performance threshold, based on a guess 
that twisting will do that, so do whatever... As long as 
you're thinking, what happens when the wrap tightens up and 
you put another turn in the wire past that point?
Ron N



More information about the pianotech mailing list

This PTG archive page provided courtesy of Moy Piano Service, LLC