Hi Joe, I would agree that the more collapsed the panel, in general, the better will be the tuning stability, provided that the seniority of the instrument isn't also accompanied with a development of poor string rendering, which is common with S&S and the myriad others who have longish/stiff under-string felt with unhardened and wide-ish counter-bearing bars. But if the rendering is fine, a dead board will invariably result in outstanding stability. Ron O. >I have a client with a S&S Model "O". (early version of the current Model >"L"). The piano was his Mother's piano. When it first arrived, I assessed >it's condition and told the client that the piano was "shot". The >soundboard had many screws through to ribs to curtail buzzes. Lots of >cracks in the board. The Killer Octave had reduced sustain. Basic S.B. >shape was a "W"! Y'all know the symptoms, (or at least your should<G>). The >basic design of the Bass bridge was wrong, (no pairs of bi-chord strings >were equal, causing difficulty in unison tuning). And, there were hair-line >cracks at the bridge pins. Bass tone/projection was adequate. Several loose >tuning pins were noted with the initial tuning process. Tonal condition of >the strings is good. >The action was really toast! All original and 90 years old!l Plus, major >Vertigris problems. The dampers were still working, so not in the mix of >"problems". <G> Original finish?, ......Alligatored..Major! The client >doesn't care about the "finish".<G> >I have since CA'd the loose tuning pins. The bass bridge I can live with. >The piano is in a small, acoustically "live", living room, so lack of >power, is not an issue. The lack of sustain in the killer octave does not >bother the owner, since the piano is used mainly in string quartet chamber >music sort of thangs. Also, the action has been completely rebuilt, w/new >N.Y. Parts and Wurzen Hammers. At this point the piano is extremely stable, >especially in the killer octave. It sounds great in this environment, imo >and the owners.<G> >This leads me to a question: Because the soundboard is "shot", I suspect >that the tuning stability is due to the fact that the soundboard is not as >reactive to climatic changes, as would a new "lively" board. Any one care >to comment?<G> >Regards, > >Joe Garrett, R.P.T. >Captain of the Tool Police >Squares R I -- OVERS PIANOS - SYDNEY Grand Piano Manufacturers _______________________ Web http://overspianos.com.au mailto:ron at overspianos.com.au _______________________ A web page with images of recent work and almost-audio-CD quality mp3 sound files of the Overs piano can be found at; http://overspianos.com.au/more_info.htm So put on your headphones, plug them into your freshly restarted computer and sit back to over 20 minutes of pure piano. _______________________
This PTG archive page provided courtesy of Moy Piano Service, LLC