Just for edification. No one held up anything at all as gospel. Indeed, quite the opposite. An example was used along with several others to make a pretty straightforward point thats all. Aside from the below and a couple similar lines laced in a post or two... I dont really see where there is much disagreement in whats being said here. ymmvoc :) Certainly nothing basic to the main concerns facing the voicer. Cheers RicB The danger, suggested in another post, of holding up one manufacturer's master voicer's opinion as the gospel on what makes good piano tone is that each manufacturer has their own tonal model. David Love
This PTG archive page provided courtesy of Moy Piano Service, LLC