David, The kind of damping problem you are experiencing may not be related to the dampers themselves. There are a number of piano designs, large uprights and squares, that seem to promote poor damping due to the soundboard not the strings. In these the sound will continue even if all the strings are muted. I am not sure exactly how this happens but speculate that an area of soundbaord is either too far from the bridges or insufficiently stiff either by being too thin or lack of downbearing. In your case maybe the board is flat and the bearing does not compress the far corners enough. John Hartman RPT NYC Chapter Hudson Valley Piano Craft (Piano Rebuilding) "It aint just tuning!" Old Steinway man.
This PTG archive page provided courtesy of Moy Piano Service, LLC