Well,.. lets see.. what do we have here.. Several fingers have been raised about selling out years of experience too cheaply. Points have been made about enabling any hobby-ist to compete, or do it himself. And points have been made about newbies not paying their "dues" (and I am refering to more then just the annual PTG membership dues). Seems to me that the first point is the most valid. One definately does not want to give this away to cheaply. If 100 bucks is too cheap well ok make it more. Its certainly worth more. As far as the hobby-ist is concerned. I say bring em on. I have cleaned up through years on these types of guys. There are usually two types. The guy who tries it once and blows it big time, then gets tired and does it himself on something else, like his VW or something. The other guy is the one who figures he can make a few fast bucks by reading a book, buying a machine and calling himself a pro. Now I am the first to get angry at some half bit fraud who goes around stealing peoples money by panning himself off as a piano tech and in the process wrecking peoples pianos. But this is a problem that cannot ever really solved. Fortunatly, these guys are eating at the bottom (of the latrine) end of the market, and even then eventually dissapear often as not. In any case I cant see them as any threat to me. Good buisness sense, hard work, reasonable marketing and I am assured of a nice fat living. The only competition I "fear" is the kind that does me the most good. Another professional, who strives to do the best he/she can. I gots to keep on my toes to meet that kind of "threat". And besides, customers who use these guys are most often (tho not always) the kind of customers I prefer to do without. As far as newbies paying their dues is concerned. They will in time, they most certainly will. And hopefully when they reach the age of 40 years or more experience they will be just as willing to help the new generation learn the ropes as the present one is. You guys who have created the PTG, helped it grow, and kept it going have something to be very proud of. And from one who has stayed on the sidelines all to long (for reasons I will not get into) I tip my hat off to you. If I could re-do the past 25 years in this regard I would, but past is past. The point is you all have something to be very proud of. Your offering of knowledge to your fellow humans may or may not be misused, but that does not take away from the honour you bestow upon yourselves by shareing what you know. There is no form of protectionist policy that in the end is anything more then self destructive. In the end a positivist attitude will accomplish more, both for your own income, and the furthering of the art. It always does. Richard Brekne
This PTG archive page provided courtesy of Moy Piano Service, LLC