I had an old Starr upright that I bought to learn to tune on (I actually paid money for it :-(). I practiced and practiced tuning. I would tune it to the SAT several times, and after each time, the pitch would be all over the place. After a few months, I finally gave up on that piano - kinda figured I would never tune a piano - and tried to tune my Steinway. No problem. I put the strings at a certain pitch and they stayed there (well, more or less). I tried other pianos. No problems, they tuned just fine. The problem was the old Starr. It would never stabilize. I fixed the pinblock separation before I even tried to tune it. I could never figure out what the problem with that piano was. Although since then, I have fixed it. I cut the piano up. Parts of the pinblock and backposts are incorporated into my new overhead drill press jig! :-) Terry Farrell ----- Original Message ----- From: "Susan Kline" <sckline@attbi.com> To: <pianotech@ptg.org> Sent: Sunday, April 14, 2002 5:49 PM Subject: Re: Choosing the pianos > > I did stop tuning one old Starr. The piano is used for teaching several > days a week, but the treble, aside from terrible false beats, also goes > out within a day or two, in spite of some work on the bridgepins. The > tuning pins are okay. I don't know what is wrong with the thing -- > I've even wondered about a separation somewhere. > > I did a lot of useless touchups, since there was no point doing a full > tuning. Only the one area was out, anyway. Finally I refused to take > their money for work which wouldn't last. I told them that they could > have bought another old upright for what they had poured into trying to > stabilize this one. > > So -- they did something! They traded it in on a decent Everett upright. > > Why didn't I refuse to work on it years ago? > > Susan > > > > > > Ah yes and wonderful is the time when in your career you can, because of > >your ability, experience, knowledge and recognition, > > > > afford to chose only the pianos you would like to work on. > > > > David Koelzer > > > > > > >
This PTG archive page provided courtesy of Moy Piano Service, LLC