... Objectivity of Posting OT

[Isaac sur Noos]

Hi Keith,

Don is paid to write when his brand is "under attack" nothing
surprizing in fact, he evgen can be very aggressive aboutr it as I
noticed yet.

I for one write may be a little too much provocative sometime, most
generally it is because I am deceived with something and please take
it like emotional answer. I know I could try to be more neutral, but
hey ! in the end that's me, I am acting like that as well in real, so
i see no real reason to try to look differently than I am on the net.

The Stuart samples I was expecting a better tone to listen for, indeed
the piano look nice, but I feel things like voicing problems, and a
too straight tone that should not stand more power, it can be caused
by regulation or voicing, but as this came from a recording i have
suggested that was due to the compression format, and I hope it is the
final reason.

The treble and high treble sound nice the tone makes me think of some
Pleyel that lack particularely dynamics, while having a pleasing tone
whatever the way you play. But the recording does not allow me to
appreciate the tone really in the end.

So I regret if you feel my comments as being totally negative, I  most
probably try to be honestly critical, I do the same with my work daily
and hate the self contenting attitude that prevail in some trades. We
need to be confident and pleased easely but stay critical as well.

Best Regards.

Isaac OLEG





> -----Message d'origine-----
> De : pianotech-bounces@ptg.org
> [mailto:pianotech-bounces@ptg.org]De la
> part de Keith McGavern
> Envoye : samedi 14 fevrier 2004 20:51
> A : Pianotech
> Objet : RE: ... Objectivity of Posting OT
>
>
> At 10:51 AM -0800 2/14/04, Donald Mannino wrote:
> >... I felt I should respond. ...
>
> Thank you, Don, for taking the time!
>
> I, too, have noticed a certain degree of disparaging comments made
> about various products and/or things. Don't understand why
> some feel
> led to trash talk items that seem to me to be quite reasonable, all
> things considered.
>
> For instance, those two sound files Richard posted, I felt they
> offered extremely nice listening material for the list venue as it
> is, yet there were seemingly irrelevant comments made by one about
> how it didn't measure up in audio terms. I fail to understand the
> point for that. I rather enjoyed the few moments of
> listening. Thank
> you, Richard, for taking the time to make it happen.
>
> Best,
>
> Keith
>
> Keith McGavern                                    Texas
> State Association
> Registered Piano Technician                 SOONER SPRING SEMINAR
> Oklahoma Chapter 731                                  March 11-14
> Piano Technicians Guild
> http://www.ptg.org/tsa/
> USA
>
>
>
> --
> _______________________________________________
> pianotech list info: https://www.moypiano.com/resources/#archives
>