It has always been my understanding that those "lists" of temperament offsets are purely calculations of paper tunings not accounting for inharmonicity. This would be the same as tuning equal by setting every note at 0.00 on the machine. I think there have in some cases allowances been made to calculate with FAC numbers, for example, but I don't use it myself. My point being is that's important to know the difference. It wouldn't be acceptable to tune an equal this way, and there's more at risk here.....(IMO). If a tuning labeled "equal" comes out unsatisfactory then the tuner is responsible. If a tuning labeled "unequal" proves unsatisfactory, then usually it is the class of unequal temperament that takes the brunt. Touchy issue, of course, ....but maybe that is beginning to change now too. cheers- dennis johnson St. Olaf College
This PTG archive page provided courtesy of Moy Piano Service, LLC