Greetings,
Not really intending to nit-pic-ric, but I got a few questions:
<<There are mentions that the Chinese knew the concept 3000 years ago>
I have nothing to do but agree with that, (just because I've been told
this often....)
>>Aristoxenes gave the math concept in 400 BC (ca)<<
It was my understanding that Aristoxenes promotoed a 12 notes scale
consisting of 10 equal steps and two larger ones. If this is correct, I
don't think we should consider Aris to have been promoting what we are
pointing to as ET>>
<Vicenzo Galilei in 1581 for ET on the lute. (18/17 ratio)>
Yes, dang close to ET, but did he not admit to the slight compromise?
<<Mersenne gives very close monochord lengths for ET in 1635.>
I read Jorgensen to state that Mersenne gave the definitive mathematical
ratios for ET.
<<James Broadwood writes how to tune it in 1811.>>
I was not aware that Broadwood wrote "how" to tune it, just that his
factory was then using "ET",( but Hipkins and Ellis seem to offer a different
point of view>
<<Claude Montal tuning instructions of 1837>>
Were not the Montal writings published in 1832? (Not sure on this one
either)
Dang, the coffee cup is empty, it is 5:30, and I gotta go begin a four
piano, one pinblock day,
Regards all,
Ed Foote RPT
This PTG archive page provided courtesy of Moy Piano Service, LLC