Opinions Please

JIMRPT@AOL.COM JIMRPT@AOL.COM
Sun, 18 Mar 2001 21:50:50 EST


In a message dated 3/18/2001 7:04:08 PM, Lance wrote:

<<"1)In your opinions, do kinked, dented, or bent (depending on what you want

to call them) wire in the speaking length section near the agraffes and

V-bar of a piano affect the piano's sound i.e., false beats?">>

Lance I have never been able to induce "false beats" by intentionally bending 
strings. Doing a very thorough job of string leveling will "kink" or 
"bend"(sic)
strings...does this induce "false beats"?
 If however the string has an obvious "dent" in it, then perhaps it would be 
wise to replace that string.


<<"2)Does it affect the pianos tunability or the ability to tune good 
unisons?">>
See above.......but I would say not.


<<"3)Would you say that a Steinway D, 5 years old with this condition

throughout the tenor and lower treble is less desirable than one without the

condition?">>
While it is not uncommon for S&S Ds, of all ages, to have false beats in the 
sections you describe....though rarely would the cause be a particular 
string, per se.


<<"4)Can this condition be _eliminated_ by any method short of restringing?">>
This ""kinked and bent" condition can be massaged out with a hammer shank or 
a soft brass rod.........any that can not be staightened to a large extent 
should be evaluated carefully before replacing the string............any 
false beats may 'not' be coming from the string and replacing may just be 
cosmetic application of time.
Just my opinion.
Jim Bryant (FL)



This PTG archive page provided courtesy of Moy Piano Service, LLC